SmallBizHandbook.com

Free compliance guides for small business owners, state by state.

Search

Formation

Sole Proprietorship vs LLC: What Changes, What Doesn't, What It Costs

On this page

Short answer: the big difference is liability. A sole proprietor is personally on the hook for business debts and lawsuits; an LLC owner generally isn't. Taxes are the same by default: a single-member LLC files the same Schedule C. What you pay for the protection is your state's formation fee and annual report (and minimum tax in a few states). Pick your state below to see the actual number.

Last updated

What an LLC costs in your state vs a sole proprietorship

Five-year state cost from each state's fee schedule, plus your 2026 federal tax (identical under both by default).

This calculator works in your browser and needs JavaScript.

Side-by-side comparison

Sole proprietorshipSingle-member LLC
How it startsAutomatically, when you start doing business on your ownFile articles (or a certificate) of organization with the state
Liability for business debtsUnlimited: you are the businessGenerally limited to the company; members aren't liable just for being members
Your own negligence or guaranteesYou're liableStill liable: the LLC doesn't shield your own acts or debts you personally guarantee
Federal income tax (default)Schedule C on Form 1040Same: a single-member LLC is a disregarded entity (Schedule C); 2+ members file Form 1065
Self-employment taxOn net earnings from self-employmentSame by default; can elect S-corp status to pay FICA only on a salary
State costsNone for the entity (DBA and licenses may apply)Formation fee plus an annual or biennial report and any minimum tax
Business nameYour legal name, or a registered DBA / assumed nameThe LLC's name with "LLC"; DBAs optional
Ownership changesEnds with you; selling means selling assetsMembership interests can be transferred under the operating agreement
Registered agentNot requiredRequired in most states

Sources: SBA "Choose a business structure"; IRS single-member LLC and LLC pages; 6 Del. C. § 18-303 as an example of the member liability rule.

Liability: what an LLC does and doesn't protect

Protected (generally)

  • The company's contracts, bills and loans you didn't personally guarantee
  • Judgments against the company, including for an employee's mistakes on the job
  • Your home, savings and personal investments from those business claims

Delaware's statute is typical: LLC debts "shall be solely the debts, obligations and liabilities of the limited liability company," and no member is personally obligated "solely by reason of being a member" ( 6 Del. C. § 18-303).

Not protected

  • Your own negligence or professional malpractice
  • Loans, leases and credit lines you personally guarantee (a member can agree to be personally liable under § 18-303(b))
  • Trust-fund payroll taxes the IRS can assess against responsible persons
  • Claims where a court disregards the LLC because personal and business money were mixed

Charging order protection varies by state

When you're sued personally, LLC statutes usually limit your creditor to a charging order on your distributions. Delaware makes that the exclusive remedy whether the LLC has one member or more (§ 18-703(d)). Florida does not for single-member LLCs: a court can order a foreclosure sale of the member's whole interest if a charging order won't pay the judgment within a reasonable time (Fla. Stat. § 605.0503(4)). If asset protection from personal creditors is your main goal, check your own state's statute.

When an LLC is worth it

  • You sign contracts or leases, where a claim or unpaid bill would otherwise be yours personally.
  • Customers, employees or the public could be hurt by your work, products, premises or vehicles.
  • You have assets to protect: home equity, savings, investments.
  • You have a co-owner: without an entity you're a general partnership, which SBA describes as unlimited personal liability.
  • Profit is high enough that an S-corp election could pay (only entities can elect it).
  • Clients or platforms require it, or you want a separate business identity for banking and credit.

A sole proprietorship is reasonable for low-risk work (writing, tutoring, design from home) at modest profit, or in a state where the LLC's yearly cost is a large share of your profit. Not sure? Take the business structure quiz.

Names and DBAs

A sole proprietor operates under their own legal name unless they register an assumed name (DBA, trade name or fictitious name), which states or counties handle and charge for. An LLC operates under its registered name and can also file a DBA. Neither a DBA nor a trade name creates liability protection. DBA rules and fees by state.

How to convert a sole proprietorship to an LLC

  1. Check the name and file your state's formation document (state-by-state LLC guide), naming a registered agent.
  2. Adopt an operating agreement (New York requires a written one). Free operating agreement generator.
  3. Sort out the EIN: a no-employee single-member LLC with default tax treatment can keep using your sole-proprietor EIN; an LLC with employees or excise taxes needs its own (EIN rules).
  4. Open a business bank account in the LLC's name and stop mixing personal and business money.
  5. Assign contracts, leases and equipment to the LLC; update licenses, permits, insurance and your invoices.
  6. Calendar the annual report and any minimum tax (due dates by state).

Frequently asked questions

Is an LLC better than a sole proprietorship?

For most businesses with real customers, contracts, employees or physical risk, yes: an LLC separates business debts and lawsuits from your personal assets for a modest state fee. A sole proprietorship can be enough for a low-risk side business or while you test an idea, especially in states where keeping an LLC is expensive (California's annual LLC tax is $800).

Do LLCs pay more tax than sole proprietors?

Not by default. The IRS disregards a single-member LLC for income tax, so you report the same profit on the same Schedule C and pay the same self-employment tax. What changes is state fees and minimum taxes, plus the option to elect S-corp taxation later.

Does an LLC protect my personal assets from everything?

No. It protects you from the company's debts and obligations, not from your own negligence or malpractice, debts you personally guarantee (common with business loans and leases), or unpaid payroll taxes the IRS can collect from responsible persons. Courts can also disregard the LLC if you commingle personal and business money. Insurance still matters.

What is charging order protection?

If you're personally sued, a creditor generally can't take the LLC's assets; a court can issue a charging order that gives the creditor your distributions. How strong that is varies: Delaware makes the charging order the exclusive remedy whether the LLC has one member or more, while Florida lets a court order a foreclosure sale of a single-member LLC's interest if distributions won't pay the judgment in a reasonable time.

Do I need a DBA as a sole proprietor?

Usually only if you do business under a name other than your own legal name. Rules and fees are set by your state, county or both; see our DBA guide for your state.

How do I switch from a sole proprietorship to an LLC?

Form the LLC with your state, adopt an operating agreement, then move the business into it: open a bank account in the LLC's name, transfer equipment and contracts, update licenses and permits, and tell customers and vendors. If the LLC has no employees and keeps the default tax treatment, the IRS lets you keep using your sole-proprietor EIN; if it will have employees or excise taxes, it needs its own EIN.