SmallBizHandbook.com

Free compliance guides for small business owners, state by state.

Search

Employment Law

At-Will Employment States (2026): Exceptions, Montana & What You Can't Fire For

On this page

Short answer: Employment is presumed at-will in every state except Montana — you can end it for any lawful reason, or none, without notice. Montana requires good cause after a probationary period (12 months by default). Everywhere, at-will stops at illegal reasons: discrimination, retaliation for complaints or protected leave, and — depending on the state — firings that violate public policy, break an implied promise or are made in bad faith.

Last updated

At-will exceptions by state

The outlines of the states are a simplified adaptation of "Blank US Map (states only).svg" by Theshibboleth, from Wikimedia Commons, as the file stood in January 2017: the revision uploaded on 19 January 2017, https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/archive/1/1a/20181115183559%21Blank_US_Map_%28states_only%29.svg, whose description page of that time, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=269987342, credits it to Theshibboleth and offers it under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported licence (CC BY-SA 3.0), https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/. The paths came here through the react-usa-map package 1.5.0 and @mirawision/usa-map-react 2.0.2, whose README says its paths are based on react-usa-map's. Here each outline is simplified to within 0.5 of a unit of the 959 by 593 drawing and rounded to whole units, and the District of Columbia is drawn as a small circle. This simplified outline is offered under the same licence, CC BY-SA 3.0, https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/. The code of the two packages is offered under the MIT licence; their notices follow. @mirawision/usa-map-react 2.0.2, LICENSE: MIT License Copyright (c) 2024 Yelysei Lukin Permission is hereby granted, free of charge, to any person obtaining a copy of this software and associated documentation files (the "Software"), to deal in the Software without restriction, including without limitation the rights to use, copy, modify, merge, publish, distribute, sublicense, and/or sell copies of the Software, and to permit persons to whom the Software is furnished to do so, subject to the following conditions: The above copyright notice and this permission notice shall be included in all copies or substantial portions of the Software. THE SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED "AS IS", WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO THE WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE AND NONINFRINGEMENT. IN NO EVENT SHALL THE AUTHORS OR COPYRIGHT HOLDERS BE LIABLE FOR ANY CLAIM, DAMAGES OR OTHER LIABILITY, WHETHER IN AN ACTION OF CONTRACT, TORT OR OTHERWISE, ARISING FROM, OUT OF OR IN CONNECTION WITH THE SOFTWARE OR THE USE OR OTHER DEALINGS IN THE SOFTWARE. react-usa-map 1.5.0, LICENSE.md: Copyright (c) 2017 Gabriela D'Ávila Ferrara Permission is hereby granted, free of charge, to any person obtaining a copy of this software and associated documentation files (the "Software"), to deal in the Software without restriction, including without limitation the rights to use, copy, modify, merge, publish, distribute, sublicense, and/or sell copies of the Software, and to permit persons to whom the Software is furnished to do so, subject to the following conditions: The above copyright notice and this permission notice shall be included in all copies or substantial portions of the Software. THE SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED "AS IS", WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO THE WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE AND NONINFRINGEMENT. IN NO EVENT SHALL THE AUTHORS OR COPYRIGHT HOLDERS BE LIABLE FOR ANY CLAIM, DAMAGES OR OTHER LIABILITY, WHETHER IN AN ACTION OF CONTRACT, TORT OR OTHERWISE, ARISING FROM, OUT OF OR IN CONNECTION WITH THE SOFTWARE OR THE USE OR OTHER DEALINGS IN THE SOFTWARE.AlaskaAll three exceptionsAKAlabamaTwo exceptionsALArkansasTwo exceptionsARArizonaAll three exceptionsAZCaliforniaAll three exceptionsCAColoradoTwo exceptionsCOConnecticutTwo exceptionsCTDistrict of ColumbiaTwo exceptionsDCDelawareTwo exceptionsDEFloridaNone of the threeFLGeorgiaNone of the threeGAHawaiiTwo exceptionsHIIowaTwo exceptionsIAIdahoAll three exceptionsIDIllinoisTwo exceptionsILIndianaOne exceptionINKansasTwo exceptionsKSKentuckyTwo exceptionsKYLouisianaNone of the threeLAMassachusettsTwo exceptionsMAMarylandTwo exceptionsMDMaineOne exceptionMEMichiganTwo exceptionsMIMinnesotaTwo exceptionsMNMissouriOne exceptionMOMississippiTwo exceptionsMSMontanaMontana — good cause required after probationMTNorth CarolinaOne exceptionNCNorth DakotaTwo exceptionsNDNebraskaOne exceptionNENew HampshireTwo exceptionsNHNew JerseyTwo exceptionsNJNew MexicoTwo exceptionsNMNevadaAll three exceptionsNVNew YorkOne exceptionNYOhioTwo exceptionsOHOklahomaTwo exceptionsOKOregonTwo exceptionsORPennsylvaniaOne exceptionPARhode IslandNone of the threeRISouth CarolinaTwo exceptionsSCSouth DakotaTwo exceptionsSDTennesseeTwo exceptionsTNTexasOne exceptionTXUtahAll three exceptionsUTVirginiaOne exceptionVAVermontTwo exceptionsVTWashingtonTwo exceptionsWAWisconsinTwo exceptionsWIWest VirginiaTwo exceptionsWVWyomingAll three exceptionsWY
  • 1 Montana — good cause required after probation
  • 7 All three exceptions
  • 30 Two exceptions
  • 9 One exception
  • 4 None of the three
Color = how many of the three common-law exceptions each state's courts had recognized, per the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics' 50-state compilation. Every state's row is in the table below. Map outline adapted from “Blank US Map (states only).svg” by Theshibboleth, CC BY-SA 3.0.

This checker works in your browser and needs JavaScript.

The three common-law exceptions

Public policy (43 jurisdictions)

No firing for refusing to commit an illegal act, reporting a violation of law, performing a public duty (jury service) or exercising a legal right (filing a workers' comp claim). Most states limit "public policy" to what's in a constitution or statute.

Implied contract (38)

Handbooks, offer letters, policies or oral assurances can promise job security or a set discipline process. A clear, prominent at-will disclaimer — and not calling employees "permanent" — is the standard defense.

Good faith and fair dealing (11)

The narrowest: bars terminations in bad faith, such as firing a salesperson just before a large commission is due or an older worker to avoid vesting retirement benefits.

Counts are from the BLS Monthly Labor Review compilation (50 states + DC, case law as of Oct. 1, 2000). Many online lists give no cases or dates; we show the government compilation as published and flag its date rather than guess state by state.

Montana: the one good-cause state

Montana's Wrongful Discharge from Employment Act (Mont. Code Ann. §§ 39-2-901 to 39-2-915) replaced common-law wrongful-discharge claims (§ 39-2-913). A discharge is wrongful only if (§ 39-2-904):

  • Good cause means reasonable job-related grounds based on failure to satisfactorily perform job duties, disruption of the employer's operation, material or repeated violation of an express written policy, or other legitimate business reasons determined by the employer exercising reasonable business judgment. (§ 39-2-903). Employers get the broadest discretion for managers and supervisors.
  • Probation: 12 months if you don't set one before work begins; you may extend it before it ends, up to 18 months in total; leaves of absence don't count unless you elect to include them (§ 39-2-910, added 2021). During probation, either side can end employment on notice for any reason.
  • Deadlines: suit within 1 year of discharge. If you have a written internal appeal procedure, tell the employee about it within 14 days; they must use it first, but may sue after 90 days (§ 39-2-911).
  • Damages: lost wages and fringe benefits for up to 4 years, minus interim earnings; punitive damages only for actual fraud or malice in a public-policy retaliation case (§ 39-2-905).
  • Not covered: discharges challenged under another statute (e.g., discrimination laws) and employees under a union contract or a written contract for a specific term (§ 39-2-912).
  1. Retaliation for refusing to violate public policy or for reporting a violation of public policy
  2. Discharge without good cause after the employee completed the employer's probationary period
  3. A material violation of the employer's own written personnel policy that cost the employee a fair chance to keep the job
  4. Discharge based solely on the employee's lawful free speech, including social media posts (added 2023)

Reasons you can't fire an at-will employee (federal law)

Firing because of…LawEmployers covered
Race, color, religion, sex (incl. pregnancy, sexual orientation, gender identity), national originTitle VII15+ employees
Race or ethnicity42 U.S.C. § 1981Any employer
Disability; pregnancy-related limitations; genetic informationADA, PWFA, GINA15+ employees
Age 40 or olderADEA20+ employees
Complaining about discrimination or taking part in an investigationTitle VII § 704, ADA, ADEA, EPASame as the underlying law (EPA: any size)
Asking about or complaining of unpaid wages or overtimeFLSA § 15(a)(3)FLSA-covered employers (nearly all)
Taking or asking for FMLA leaveFMLA § 10550+ employees
Military serviceUSERRAAny employer
Federal jury service28 U.S.C. § 1875Any employer (state laws protect state jurors)
Reporting a safety hazardOSH Act § 11(c)Any private employer
Discussing pay or working conditions with coworkers; union activityNLRA §§ 7–8Most private employers
A single wage garnishmentConsumer Credit Protection ActAny employer
To keep someone from getting pension or health benefitsERISA § 510Employers with ERISA plans
Citizenship or immigration status (if authorized to work)INA § 274B4+ employees

State laws add more — most state discrimination laws reach smaller employers and protect extra classes; many states protect workers' comp claimants, jurors and voters, and a few (e.g., Colorado and North Dakota) protect lawful off-duty activities. See discrimination laws by state.

All 50 states + DC: at-will exceptions (BLS compilation)

Source: Muhl, "The employment-at-will doctrine: three major exceptions," Monthly Labor Review, Jan. 2001, Exhibit 1 — recognition as of Oct. 1, 2000 (from Walsh & Schwarz, 33 Am. Bus. L.J. 645, with case law shepardized). 1 BLS footnote: overturned a previous decision that was contrary to current doctrine. For Montana, the WDEA (1987) now governs; the BLS columns are shown as published.

StateDefault rulePublic policyImplied contractGood faith
AlabamaAt-willNoYesYes
AlaskaAt-willYesYesYes
ArizonaAt-willYesYesYes
ArkansasAt-willYesYesNo
CaliforniaAt-willYesYesYes
ColoradoAt-willYesYesNo
ConnecticutAt-willYesYesNo
DelawareAt-willYesNoYes
District of ColumbiaAt-willYesYesNo
FloridaAt-willNoNoNo
GeorgiaAt-willNoNoNo
HawaiiAt-willYesYesNo
IdahoAt-willYesYesYes
IllinoisAt-willYesYesNo
IndianaAt-willYesNoNo
IowaAt-willYesYesNo
KansasAt-willYesYes¹No
KentuckyAt-willYesYesNo
LouisianaAt-willNoNoNo
MaineAt-willNoYesNo
MarylandAt-willYesYesNo
MassachusettsAt-willYesNoYes
MichiganAt-willYesYesNo
MinnesotaAt-willYesYesNo
MississippiAt-willYes¹YesNo
MissouriAt-willYesNo¹No
MontanaGood cause after probationYesNoYes
NebraskaAt-willNoYesNo
NevadaAt-willYesYesYes
New HampshireAt-willYesYesNo¹
New JerseyAt-willYesYesNo
New MexicoAt-willYesYesNo
New YorkAt-willNoYesNo
North CarolinaAt-willYesNoNo
North DakotaAt-willYesYesNo
OhioAt-willYes¹YesNo
OklahomaAt-willYesYesNo
OregonAt-willYesYesNo
PennsylvaniaAt-willYesNoNo
Rhode IslandAt-willNoNoNo
South CarolinaAt-willYesYesNo
South DakotaAt-willYesYesNo
TennesseeAt-willYesYesNo
TexasAt-willYesNoNo
UtahAt-willYesYesYes
VermontAt-willYesYesNo
VirginiaAt-willYesNoNo
WashingtonAt-willYesYesNo
West VirginiaAt-willYesYesNo
WisconsinAt-willYesYesNo
WyomingAt-willYesYesYes

Protecting an at-will relationship

  • Put a plain at-will statement in offer letters, applications and the handbook, and say only a named officer can change it in writing.
  • Describe discipline steps as examples you may skip, not a required sequence.
  • Document performance problems when they happen — not after a complaint.
  • Apply rules the same way to everyone; inconsistent treatment is the backbone of most discrimination claims.
  • Pause and review any termination that follows a complaint, leave request, accommodation request or injury.

Build compliant documents with the offer letter generator and employee handbook builder.

Questions

Which states are at-will employment states?

All 50 states and DC presume employment is at-will except Montana. Montana's Wrongful Discharge from Employment Act requires good cause to fire an employee who has finished the probationary period. Everywhere else, an employer may end employment for any lawful reason or none, and an employee may quit at any time, unless a contract says otherwise.

What are the exceptions to at-will employment?

Three come from court decisions: the public-policy exception (no firing for refusing to break the law, reporting illegal conduct, serving on a jury or filing a workers' comp claim), the implied-contract exception (handbooks, offer letters or oral assurances that promise job security or a discipline process), and the covenant of good faith and fair dealing (no bad-faith firings, e.g., to avoid paying earned commissions). In the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics' 50-state compilation (case law as of October 2000), 43 jurisdictions recognized the first, 38 the second and 11 the third. On top of those, statutes ban firing for discrimination, retaliation and protected leave.

How does Montana's at-will law work?

Under Mont. Code Ann. § 39-2-904, a discharge is wrongful if it was retaliation for refusing to violate or reporting a violation of public policy; it lacked good cause after probation; the employer materially broke its own written personnel policy; or (since 2023) it was based solely on lawful free speech, including social media. If you don't set a probationary period, it's 12 months; you can extend it, up to 18 months in total. Claims must be filed within 1 year and lost wages are capped at 4 years.

Can I fire an at-will employee without giving a reason?

In every state but Montana (after probation) you generally don't have to give one. But if the employee later claims discrimination or retaliation, you'll need to show the real, lawful reason — so decide and document it before acting, even if you don't share it.

Is at-will the same as right-to-work?

No. At-will is about whether you need a reason to fire someone. Right-to-work laws are about whether union membership or dues can be a condition of employment in a unionized workplace. A state can be both, either or neither — every state except Montana is at-will, while only some are right-to-work.

Does a probationary period change at-will status?

Outside Montana, no — employees are at-will before and after probation, and describing employees as 'permanent' after probation can create an implied-contract argument. In Montana the probationary period matters: after it ends, good cause is required.

Do I have to give two weeks' notice when firing someone?

No federal or state law requires notice for an individual at-will termination (Montana probationers get notice-based termination under its statute). Advance notice is required for mass layoffs and plant closings under the federal WARN Act at 100+ employees and some state laws, and contracts or union agreements may require it.