LLC vs S Corp: Differences, Taxes and When to Elect (2026)
Last updated: 2026-10-07 · 2026 federal and state figures checked 2026-10-07
The short answer
An LLC is the business; an S corp is a tax election the LLC can make. Electing S lets you pay payroll tax only on a reasonable salary instead of 15.3% SE tax on all profit — but it adds payroll, a separate corporate return, a smaller QBI deduction and, in some states, an entity tax. It pays off only when profit is well above a reasonable salary for your work. Check your numbers below.
Quick check: should your LLC elect S-corp status?
Single filer, no other income, IRS-average $4,200 return cost, your state's 2026 payroll taxes and S-corp rules.
Change costs, filing status, other income and the salary helper in the full S-corp tax savings calculator.
LLC (default tax) vs LLC taxed as an S corp
| LLC, default tax | LLC taxed as an S corp | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | A state-law business entity (Articles of Organization) | A federal tax status an LLC or corporation elects with Form 2553 |
| Liability protection | Yes, from the LLC | Same — it's still your LLC (or corporation) |
| Default federal tax | One owner: disregarded (Schedule C). Two+: partnership (Form 1065) | S corporation (Form 1120-S + K-1s) |
| Self-employment / payroll tax | 15.3% SE tax on all profit (up to the wage base for the 12.4% part) | FICA only on your W-2 salary; K-1 profit has no SE tax |
| Owner pay | Draws — no payroll needed | Reasonable W-2 salary through payroll, then distributions |
| QBI deduction (20%) | On nearly all profit; above $201,750 taxable income ($403,500 joint) it phases down unless the business pays W-2 wages or owns property | Only on K-1 profit — salary isn't QBI, but it counts as W-2 wages for the high-income limit |
| Owners | Any number, any type (people, companies, foreign owners) | Up to 100; individuals, estates, certain trusts; no nonresident aliens, partnerships or corporations |
| Splitting profits | Flexible (partnership allocations) | Strictly by ownership — one class of stock |
| Federal filings | Schedule C (or Form 1065) | Form 1120-S, payroll Forms 941/940, W-2/W-3 |
| State taxes | LLC fees and taxes (e.g., California $800 + fee) | Some states add S-corp taxes (CA 1.5%, IL 1.5%, NJ minimum, NYC/DC corporate tax) |
| Retirement plan base | Net SE earnings (solo 401(k) employer share ≈ 20%) | W-2 salary only (employer share 25% of salary) |
Break-even profit by salary (2026)
Profit at which the S corp starts saving money — Texas, single filer, no other income; includes the QBI effect, FUTA and Texas unemployment tax.
| Reasonable salary | Break-even, no added costs | Break-even, $4,200 return cost |
|---|---|---|
| $40,000 | $49,500 | $77,800 |
| $60,000 | $77,300 | $108,700 |
| $80,000 | $110,300 | $137,200 |
| $100,000 | $139,300 | $168,200 |
$4,200 is the IRS's average out-of-pocket burden for small S corporations (Instructions for Form 1120-S); actual quotes vary. The salary must be reasonable for the work, so you can't lower it just to reach break-even.
Signs the S election fits — and signs it doesn't
- Profit consistently far above a market salary for your role
- Steady income (you can run payroll every month)
- One owner or a few U.S. owners with identical economics
- A state without an S-corp-level tax
- Profit close to what you'd pay someone to do your job
- New or volatile business, or losses expected
- Foreign or entity owners, or profit splits that don't match ownership
- Business in New York City or DC at modest profits (S corps pay an 8.85% / 8.25% corporate-level tax there)
State differences that matter
- California: S corps pay 1.5% of California net income (minimum $800) instead of the LLC's $800 annual tax and gross-receipts fee. Source
- Illinois: S corps pay the 1.5% Personal Property Replacement Income Tax on Illinois net income; sole proprietors and single-member LLCs don't. Source
- Massachusetts: S corps owe at least the $456 corporate minimum excise; the income measure applies only at $6 million+ in receipts. Source
- New Jersey: S corps pay a minimum tax of $375–$1,500 based on New Jersey gross receipts. Source
- New York: S corps pay a fixed-dollar minimum of $25–$4,500 by New York receipts. New York City doesn't recognize S status: the S corp pays the 8.85% General Corporation Tax. Source
- District of Columbia: An S corp pays DC's 8.25% corporate franchise tax ($250 minimum). A personal-services SMLLC is often exempt from DC's unincorporated business tax, so electing S can add the full 8.25%. Source
- Oregon: S corps pay Oregon's $150 minimum tax; a single-member LLC owes no entity tax. Source
- Vermont: S corps (including LLCs that elect S) pay Vermont's $250 minimum business entity tax; a disregarded SMLLC doesn't. Source
- Minnesota: S corps owe a minimum fee only when Minnesota property, payroll and sales total $1,280,000 or more (2026); below that it's $0. Source
- Tennessee: Franchise (0.25% of net worth, $100 minimum) and excise (6.5%) taxes apply to single-member LLCs and S corps alike — electing S doesn't change them. Source
- Texas: The franchise tax applies to LLCs and corporations the same way; reports due in 2026–2027 owe no tax below $2.65 million in revenue. Source
- New Hampshire: The Business Profits Tax (7.5%) and Business Enterprise Tax (0.55%) apply to sole proprietors too, above the filing thresholds. Source
- Louisiana: The corporation franchise tax is repealed for periods beginning on or after Jan. 1, 2026, and S corps owe no entity-level income tax. Source
- Utah: Utah's corporate minimum tax doesn't apply to S corporations. Source
Next steps
- Model it with your costs and salary: S-corp tax savings calculator.
- Check eligibility, the Form 2553 deadline and state elections: how to elect S-corp status.
- Still choosing a structure? Business structure quiz · LLC cost calculator.
- Staying an LLC? See your self-employment tax and quarterly payments.
Frequently asked questions
Is it LLC or S corp — do I have to choose?
No. LLC is the legal entity; S corp is a way of being taxed. Most small businesses that "become an S corp" are LLCs that filed Form 2553. You keep the LLC, its liability protection and operating agreement.
When should an LLC elect S-corp status?
When your profit is consistently well above a reasonable salary for the work you do — enough that the 15.3% payroll tax saved on the difference beats the cost of payroll, the 1120-S return, any state S-corp tax and the smaller QBI deduction. The break-even depends on your salary and costs; the table and quick check on this page compute it.
Is there a profit level where S corps always make sense?
No. Rules of thumb ($40,000, $50,000, $60,000) don't account for your reasonable salary, your state or your costs. In Texas with a $60,000 salary, break-even is about $77,300 of profit even with no added costs and $108,700 with the IRS-average $4,200 return cost. In New York City and DC the S corp also pays a corporate-level tax (8.85% / 8.25%), which pushes break-even higher still.
How does an LLC elect S-corp status?
File IRS Form 2553, signed by all members, within 2 months and 15 days of the start of the tax year the election should take effect (March 15, 2027 for calendar-year 2027) or any time in the prior year. The LLC doesn't need to file Form 8832 first. Then set up payroll and check whether your state needs its own election (New York does).
Can a multi-member LLC be an S corp?
Yes, if every member is an eligible shareholder and the LLC has effectively one class of ownership — distributions must follow ownership percentages. LLCs with special allocations, preferred returns or foreign members usually can't qualify without restructuring.
Does an S corp election change my liability protection?
No. Liability protection comes from the state-law entity (the LLC or corporation). Keep business and personal finances separate either way.
Can I switch back from S corp to a regular LLC?
Yes, by revoking the election with consent of owners holding more than 50% of the shares. If you revoke, you generally can't re-elect for five years without IRS consent, so don't elect for a single good year.
Official Sources
Figures checked against these sources on 2026-10-07- IRS: LLC filing as a corporation or partnership
- IRS: S corporations
- IRS Form 2553 and instructions (Rev. Dec. 2020) — deadline, eligibility, late-election relief
- IRS Instructions for Form 1120-S (2025) — incl. IRS burden estimate for S corporations
- IRS: S corporation compensation and medical insurance issues — reasonable compensation factors, court cases
- IRS: Self-employment tax (Social Security and Medicare taxes)
- IRS Form 8995 instructions (qualified business income deduction)
- SBA: Choose a business structure
- IRS Publication 560, Retirement Plans for Small Business
- California FTB — S corporations
- Illinois Department of Revenue — income tax rates (replacement tax)
- Mass.gov — S corporations
- NJ Division of Taxation — CBT-100S instructions
- NY Tax Department — Form CT-3-S instructions (fixed-dollar minimum)
- DC Office of Tax and Revenue — business franchise tax rates
- Oregon DOR — corporation filing requirements
- Vermont Department of Taxes — business entity income tax
Free Tools & Calculators
Free LLC cost calculator for all 50 states + DC: filing fees, annual reports, minimum taxes, publication and 5-year totals, verified against official fee schedules.
Answer 9 questions and see why each answer points to a sole proprietorship, LLC, S-corp election or C corp, with 2026 federal tax math and your state's LLC fees. PDF summary.
Itemized startup cost worksheet by industry and state: one-time and monthly costs, cash reserve, funding gap, break-even, and the IRS $5,000 start-up deduction. Excel download with live formulas, print/PDF, CSV.
Traditional or lean SBA-format business plan with section guidance, 3-year projections, SBA debt-coverage and equity checks, and imports from the startup cost and P&L tools. Word, PDF, Excel.
Related Resources on This Site
Helpful guides
- DBA RegistrationDBA / fictitious name registration
- Home Business Permithome-based business permits
- Sales Taxsales tax rates & rules by state
- Estimated Taxesquarterly estimated taxes — when and how to pay
General information, not legal or tax advice.