Employment Law
Employee vs Independent Contractor: How to Classify Workers (2026)
On this page
The short version
- Three sets of rules apply at once: the IRS common-law test (payroll taxes), the FLSA economic-reality test (minimum wage & overtime) and your state’s tests — which often differ for wage law, unemployment insurance and workers’ comp.
- The strictest is the ABC test: the worker is an employee unless they’re free from your control, the work is outside your usual business, and they run an independent business. It applies to unemployment insurance in 17 jurisdictions and to wage law in CA, MA, NJ and (for wage payment) IL.
- Federal DOL rule: the 2024 rule isn’t enforced by DOL investigators (since May 2025); a 2026 proposal to replace it is pending — no final rule as of 2026-10-03.
- 2026 paperwork: 1099-NEC threshold is now $2,000 (was $600); forms due Feb. 1, 2027.
Last updated
Which test does your state use?
- 17 ABC test
- 6 Two-prong (A + C)
- 6 Statutory checklist / presumption
- 22 Common-law / IRS control factors
- 0 FLSA factors (state law)
- 0 Federal FLSA only (no state test verified)
- 0 Not verified
The three tests at a glance
| Test | Governs | Core question | Status (Oct. 2026) | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| IRS common-law test | Federal income tax withholding, Social Security/Medicare (FICA) and FUTA | Does the business have the right to control what is done and how? (behavioral, financial, relationship) | Unchanged; Form SS-8 gives an official ruling (wait at least six months). | IRS |
| FLSA economic-reality test | Federal minimum wage and overtime (also FMLA) | Is the worker economically dependent on you, or in business for themself? | DOL enforces using Fact Sheet #13 (2008) since May 2025; 2026 proposed rule pending. | DOL FAB 2025-1 |
| State tests (ABC, A+C, statutory, common law) | State wage laws, unemployment insurance, workers' comp, state income tax withholding | Varies — the ABC test presumes employment unless all three prongs are proven. | Differs by state and by law; see the 50-state table. | DOL UI comparison |
1. The IRS common-law test (federal payroll taxes)
The IRS asks whether the business has the right to control what work is done and how — even if it doesn’t exercise it. It groups the evidence into three categories and looks at the whole relationship; no single factor decides.
Behavioral control
Instructions on when, where and how to work; training in your methods; evaluating the process rather than the result.
Financial control
Significant investment, unreimbursed expenses, opportunity for profit or loss, services offered to the market, how they’re paid.
Type of relationship
Written contracts, employee-type benefits, permanency, and whether the services are a key activity of your business.
Older guidance lists these as 20 factors (Revenue Ruling 87-41), and several state unemployment agencies still use that list. Unsure? Either side can file Form SS-8 for an IRS determination — the IRS says it may take at least six months.
Show the IRS 20-factor list
The 20 factors come from IRS Revenue Ruling 87-41; the IRS now groups the evidence into behavioral control, financial control and the relationship of the parties, and no single factor decides. Several states still use the 20-factor list for unemployment tax (e.g., Missouri, Michigan, Texas). Category mapping is ours.
| Factor (Rev. Rul. 87-41) | Points toward employee when… | Today's IRS category |
|---|---|---|
| Instructions | Required to follow instructions on when, where and how to work | Behavioral |
| Training | Trained in the business's methods | Behavioral |
| Integration | Services are integrated into the business's operations | Relationship |
| Services rendered personally | Must do the work personally | Behavioral |
| Hiring, supervising and paying assistants | The business hires and pays any helpers | Behavioral |
| Continuing relationship | Ongoing relationship, even at irregular intervals | Relationship |
| Set hours of work | Hours are set by the business | Behavioral |
| Full time required | Must devote substantially full time to the business | Behavioral |
| Work on the employer's premises | Work done on the business's premises or route | Behavioral |
| Order or sequence set | Must perform tasks in the order the business sets | Behavioral |
| Oral or written reports | Must submit regular reports | Behavioral |
| Payment by hour, week or month | Paid by time rather than by the job | Financial |
| Payment of business/travel expenses | The business pays expenses | Financial |
| Furnishing tools and materials | The business supplies tools and materials | Financial |
| Significant investment | No significant investment by the worker | Financial |
| Realization of profit or loss | Cannot make a profit or suffer a loss | Financial |
| Working for more than one firm | Works only for this business | Financial |
| Services offered to the public | Does not offer services to the general public | Financial |
| Right to discharge | Can be fired without contract liability | Relationship |
| Right to terminate | Can quit without liability | Relationship |
2. The FLSA economic-reality test (minimum wage & overtime)
For wage-and-hour law the question is economic dependence: is the worker in business for themself, or dependent on you for work? The DOL Fact Sheet #13 factors it currently enforces with are: how integral the work is to your business; permanence of the relationship; the worker’s investment; the nature and degree of your control; the worker’s opportunity for profit or loss; and the skill, initiative and independent business organization involved.
Jan. 7, 2021
DOL publishes a rule making control and opportunity for profit/loss the two "core" factors.
Mar. 11, 2024
Biden-era rule takes effect (29 CFR part 795): six factors weighed under the totality of the circumstances. Source
May 1, 2025
Field Assistance Bulletin 2025-1: WHD stops applying the 2024 rule in investigations and enforces with Fact Sheet #13 (2008) and Opinion Letter FLSA2019-6. The 2024 rule still applies in private lawsuits. Source
Feb. 27, 2026
Proposed rule (91 FR 9932) to rescind the 2024 rule and restore a modified 2021 analysis — control and profit/loss as core factors — and apply it to the FMLA and MSPA too. Comments closed Apr. 28, 2026. Source
As of 2026-10-03
No final rule has been published in the Federal Register; the proposal is still pending. Source
What changes if the 2026 proposal is finalized: control and opportunity for profit or loss would become the two “core” factors, the others would be secondary, and the same analysis would apply to the FMLA and the Migrant and Seasonal Agricultural Worker Protection Act. State wage laws are unaffected.
3. The ABC test and other state tests
Under an ABC test the worker is presumed to be an employee unless the business proves all three:
- A — the worker is free from your control and direction in performing the work, under the contract and in fact;
- B — the work is outside the usual course of your business (in many unemployment statutes, or performed outside all of your places of business);
- C — the worker is customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation or business of the same kind.
Prong B is where most businesses fail: a marketing agency can’t treat its freelance marketers as contractors in California, but a restaurant can hire a contract web designer. Other states use a two-prong test (free from control + independent business — e.g., Colorado, Idaho, Pennsylvania unemployment), a statutory checklist (e.g., Wisconsin’s nine conditions for workers’ comp, Washington’s six-part test, West Virginia’s Employment Relationship Test Act, Maine’s 5 + 3 criteria) or the common-law/IRS control test (e.g., Texas, Missouri, North Carolina).
Worker classification tests by state (all 50 + DC)
| State | Wage & hour | Unemployment insurance | Workers' comp | Other misclassification laws |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alabama | No state wage law — FLSA | Master–servant (control) test | Not verified | — |
| Alaska | FLSA (state test not verified) | ABC test | Not verified | — |
| Arizona | FLSA (state test not verified) | Control test (statutory) | Right-to-control test | — |
| Arkansas | FLSA (state test not verified) | IRS common-law (20-factor) test | Not verified | — |
| California | ABC test (AB 5) | ABC test (AB 5) | ABC test (AB 5) | Willful misclassification penalty |
| Colorado | Two-prong test (A + C) | Two-prong test (A + C) | Two-prong test (A + C) | — |
| Connecticut | FLSA (state test not verified) | ABC test | Not verified | — |
| Delaware | FLSA (state test not verified) | ABC test | Not verified | Workplace Fraud Act (construction only) |
| District of Columbia | FLSA (state test not verified) | Contract-of-hire (common law) | Not verified | Workplace Fraud Act (construction) |
| Florida | FLSA (state test not verified) | Common-law test | Statutory test (4 of 6 criteria) | — |
| Georgia | FLSA (state test not verified) | Two-prong test (A + C) | Not verified | — |
| Hawaii | FLSA (state test not verified) | ABC test | Not verified | — |
| Idaho | FLSA (state test not verified) | Two-prong test (A + C) | Not verified | — |
| Illinois | ABC test (Wage Payment Act) | ABC test | Not verified | Employee Classification Act (construction) |
| Indiana | FLSA (state test not verified) | ABC test | Not verified | — |
| Iowa | FLSA (state test not verified) | Control / contract of hire | Not verified | — |
| Kansas | FLSA (state test not verified) | Common-law control test | Not verified | — |
| Kentucky | FLSA (state test not verified) | Master–servant (common law) | Not verified | — |
| Louisiana | No state wage law — FLSA | ABC test | Not verified | — |
| Maine | FLSA (state test not verified) | Statutory presumption + criteria | Statutory presumption + criteria | — |
| Maryland | FLSA (state test not verified) | ABC test | Not verified | Workplace Fraud Act (construction & landscaping) |
| Massachusetts | ABC test (strict) | ABC test | Contract of hire (not § 148B) | Penalties for § 148B violations |
| Michigan | FLSA (state test not verified) | IRS common-law (20-factor) test | Economic-reality style (statutory) | — |
| Minnesota | Uses the WC / UI tests | Master–servant (common law) | Not verified | Misclassification penalties (2024 amendments) |
| Mississippi | No state wage law — FLSA | Master–servant (control) test | Not verified | — |
| Missouri | FLSA (state test not verified) | Common-law right to control | Contract of hire | Knowing misclassification penalty |
| Montana | FLSA (state test not verified) | Independent-contractor exemption certificate | Not verified | — |
| Nebraska | FLSA (state test not verified) | ABC test | Not verified | — |
| Nevada | Conclusive IC presumption (wage law) | ABC test | Control as to result only | — |
| New Hampshire | 7-criteria test (wage law) | ABC test | Presumption + 7 criteria | — |
| New Jersey | ABC test (N.J.A.C. 12:11) | ABC test | Not verified | Misclassification penalties & stop-work orders |
| New Mexico | FLSA (state test not verified) | ABC test | Not verified | — |
| New York | FLSA (state test not verified) | Supervision, direction & control | Not verified | Construction Industry Fair Play Act |
| North Carolina | FLSA (state test not verified) | Federal (FUTA) common-law test | Contract of hire | — |
| North Dakota | FLSA (state test not verified) | Common-law test | Not verified | — |
| Ohio | FLSA (state test not verified) | Direction-or-control test | Common law; 20-criteria test in construction | — |
| Oklahoma | FLSA (state test not verified) | IRS common-law (20-factor) test | Not verified | — |
| Oregon | FLSA (state test not verified) | ORS 670.600 test | ORS 670.600 test | — |
| Pennsylvania | FLSA (state test not verified) | Two-prong test (A + C) | Not verified | Construction Workplace Misclassification Act (Act 72) |
| Rhode Island | FLSA factors (state law) | IRS factors | Not verified | Misclassification civil penalty |
| South Carolina | No state wage law — FLSA | Contract-of-hire (common law) | Not verified | — |
| South Dakota | FLSA (state test not verified) | Two-prong test (A + C) | Not verified | — |
| Tennessee | No state wage law — FLSA | IRS common-law (20-factor) test | 7-factor test (control primary) | — |
| Texas | TWC 20-factor test (Payday Law) | Direction-or-control (20-factor) | Statutory IC definition | — |
| Utah | FLSA (state test not verified) | Two-prong test (A + C) | Not verified | — |
| Vermont | FLSA (state test not verified) | ABC test | Not verified | — |
| Virginia | Presumed employee · IRS guidelines | Presumed employee · IRS guidelines | Presumed employee · IRS guidelines | Private right of action |
| Washington | FLSA (state test not verified) | ABC test (or 6-part alternative) | 6-part test (ABC + 3 more) | — |
| West Virginia | Employment Relationship Test Act | Employment Relationship Test Act | Employment Relationship Test Act | — |
| Wisconsin | FLSA (state test not verified) | Control + 6 of 10 conditions | All 9 conditions | Construction misclassification enforcement |
| Wyoming | FLSA (state test not verified) | Control + holds out + can substitute | Not verified | — |
Examples by industry
Illustrations only — real outcomes depend on all the facts. Run your own facts through the classification quiz.
| Situation | Key facts | IRS common-law lean | Under an ABC test |
|---|---|---|---|
| Restaurant hires a web designer to rebuild its site | Fixed fee, designer's own equipment, other clients, delivers a finished site. | Contractor | Contractor — web design is outside a restaurant's usual business (prong B), and the designer runs their own business (C). |
| Marketing agency uses a freelance social-media manager for client accounts | Works remotely, sets own hours, has other clients, but does the same work the agency sells. | Often contractor (little behavioral control) | Likely employee — the work is the agency's usual course of business, so prong B fails (unless the state's B prong accepts work done off all business premises). |
| General contractor uses a drywall crew | Crew owner has an LLC, own tools, insurance, bids jobs, and hires helpers. | Contractor | Can be a contractor, but construction-specific laws (e.g., NY Fair Play Act, PA Act 72, IL Employee Classification Act, MD Workplace Fraud Act) add extra requirements — check them. |
| Home-care agency sends aides to clients | Agency sets schedules, trains aides, bills clients by the hour. | Employee | Employee — fails prongs A and B. |
| Accounting firm hires a seasonal tax preparer | Uses firm software and office, set hours from January–April, paid hourly. | Employee — seasonal doesn't make someone a contractor | Employee — fails A and B. |
| Retail store hires an IT consultant to migrate its systems | Defined project, consultant's own firm and tools, paid per milestone. | Contractor | Contractor if the consultant has an established business serving others. |
Misclassification penalties
Federal
| Liability | Amount | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Employer share of Social Security & Medicare | 100% — 6.2% (to the $184,500 wage base) + 1.45% | IRC § 3509 does not reduce it |
| Income tax you should have withheld | 1.5% of wages (3% if you didn’t file the 1099s) | IRC § 3509(a)–(b) |
| Employee share of FICA you should have withheld | 20% of the employee share (40% without 1099s) | IRC § 3509(a)–(b) |
| Intentional disregard | Reduced § 3509 rates are not available — full withholding and FICA liability | IRC § 3509(c) |
| Unpaid minimum wage / overtime | Back wages plus an equal amount as liquidated damages, plus attorney’s fees | 29 U.S.C. § 216(b) |
| Late or missing W-2 / 1099 (returns due in 2027) | $60 per return if corrected within 30 days, $130 by Aug. 1, $340 after that; intentional disregard at least $690. Small-business annual cap at the $340 tier: $1,397,000. | Rev. Proc. 2025-32 § 4.57 |
| Interest and other penalties | Interest on underpayments plus failure-to-deposit/pay penalties may apply on top | IRS |
State misclassification laws we verified
| State | Law | What it does / penalties |
|---|---|---|
| California | Willful misclassification penalty · Cal. Lab. Code § 226.8 | $5,000–$15,000 per violation for willful misclassification; $10,000–$25,000 per violation for a pattern or practice. |
| Delaware | Workplace Fraud Act (construction only) · 19 Del. C. ch. 35 (§ 3501 et seq.) | Prohibits improperly classifying construction workers as independent contractors. |
| District of Columbia | Workplace Fraud Act (construction) · D.C. Code § 32-1331.01 et seq. | Prohibits misclassifying construction workers as independent contractors. |
| Illinois | Employee Classification Act (construction) · 820 ILCS 185/10, 185/40 | Construction workers are deemed employees unless ABC-style criteria are met. Civil penalty up to $1,000 per violation found in a first audit and up to $2,000 per repeat violation within 5 years; each worker and each day is a separate violation. |
| Maryland | Workplace Fraud Act (construction & landscaping) · Lab. & Empl. §§ 3-902, 3-903, 3-908, 3-915 | ABC-style presumption of employment in construction and landscaping. Up to $1,000 per affected employee if the employer fails to come into compliance; up to $20,000 for anyone who knowingly helps an employer evade the law. |
| Massachusetts | Penalties for § 148B violations · M.G.L. c. 149, § 27C | Willful: fine up to $25,000 and/or 1 year (first offense), up to $50,000 and/or 2 years (subsequent). Non-willful: up to $10,000 and/or 6 months, then up to $25,000 and/or 1 year. Public-works debarment can apply. |
| Minnesota | Misclassification penalties (2024 amendments) · Minn. Stat. § 181.722, subd. 4 | Up to $10,000 per individual not treated as an employee, up to $10,000 per prohibited act, plus compensatory damages; $1,000 per person who obstructs an investigation. |
| Missouri | Knowing misclassification penalty · RSMo § 285.515 | $50 per day per misclassified worker, up to $50,000, when a court finds knowing misclassification. |
| New Jersey | Misclassification penalties & stop-work orders · 2020 misclassification law package (NJDOL) | NJDOL can assess a penalty of 5% of the worker's gross earnings over the prior 12 months (paid to the worker) and issue stop-work orders. |
| New York | Construction Industry Fair Play Act · N.Y. Labor Law art. 25-B (§ 861 et seq.) | Construction workers are employees unless free from direction and control, the work is outside the hiring business's usual work, and they have an independently established business (ABC). |
| Pennsylvania | Construction Workplace Misclassification Act (Act 72) · Act 72 of 2010 (43 P.S. § 933.1 et seq.) | In construction, an independent contractor must have a written contract, be free from control, and be customarily engaged in an independent business; applies to UC, workers' comp and Act 72, with criminal and administrative penalties. |
| Rhode Island | Misclassification civil penalty · R.I. Gen. Laws § 28-14-19.1 | $1,500–$3,000 per misclassified employee for a first offense and up to $5,000 per employee for later offenses; criminal penalties in construction. |
| Virginia | Private right of action · Va. Code § 40.1-28.7:7 | A worker who was not properly classified may sue an employer that knew of the misclassification for damages. |
| Wisconsin | Construction misclassification enforcement · Wis. Stat. § 103.06 | DWD may issue stop-work orders and civil forfeitures against construction employers that misclassify workers. |
What to do if you’ve misclassified someone
Voluntary Classification Settlement Program (VCSP)
- For businesses that have treated workers as contractors and want to treat them as employees going forward.
- Pay 10% of the employment tax that would have been due for the most recent tax year, figured at § 3509(a)’s reduced rates — no interest or penalties, and no employment-tax audit of those workers for prior years.
- You must have filed the required 1099s for the workers for the previous three years and not be under an employment tax audit.
- File Form 8952 at least 120 days before the date you want to start treating them as employees.
IRS: VCSP — federal only; state agencies are not bound.
Section 530 relief
Ends federal employment-tax liability for a worker you didn’t treat as an employee if you meet all three:
- Reporting consistency — you timely filed the 1099s.
- Substantive consistency — you never treated this worker, or anyone in a substantially similar position, as an employee after 1977.
- Reasonable basis — reliance on a prior IRS audit, judicial precedent, or long-standing industry practice (or another reasonable basis).
IRS: Section 530 relief — does not cover state taxes, wage claims or workers’ comp.
Form SS-8 (official IRS determination)
A business or a worker can ask the IRS to decide a worker’s status for federal employment taxes. The IRS says a determination may take at least six months. It does not bind state agencies or the DOL.
About Form SS-8 · IRS guidance
For workers: Form 8919
A worker who should have been an employee uses Form 8919 to report only the employee share of Social Security and Medicare instead of full self-employment tax.
Employee vs contractor: practical differences
| Topic | W-2 employee | 1099 independent contractor |
|---|---|---|
| Taxes | You withhold income tax and the employee's 7.65% FICA, and pay 7.65% employer FICA + FUTA + state unemployment | No withholding (unless backup withholding applies); contractor pays 15.3% self-employment tax |
| Year-end form | Form W-2 (all employees); 2026 forms due Feb. 1, 2027 | Form 1099-NEC if paid $2,000+ in 2026; due Feb. 1, 2027 |
| Onboarding forms | Form W-4, Form I-9, state new-hire report | Form W-9 |
| Wage laws | Minimum wage, overtime, final-pay and paid-leave laws apply | Generally not covered |
| Unemployment & workers' comp | Covered — you pay premiums/taxes | Not covered; contractor insures themself |
| Control | You can direct how, when and where work is done | You specify results; they choose the methods |
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between an employee and an independent contractor?
An employee works under the business's control and is economically part of it: the business directs how and when the work is done, supplies the tools, and pays wages subject to withholding, Social Security/Medicare, unemployment tax and workers' comp. An independent contractor runs their own business: they control the methods, bear the risk of profit or loss, serve other clients, and pay their own self-employment tax. The label in a contract doesn't decide it — the actual relationship does.
Which states use the ABC test?
It depends on the law. For unemployment insurance, 17 jurisdictions in our table use an ABC test (some let prong B be met by work done outside all of the business's places of business). For wage laws, California (Lab. Code § 2775), Massachusetts (c. 149 § 148B), New Jersey (statutory ABC test, with NJDOL rules operative Oct. 1, 2026) and Illinois' Wage Payment and Collection Act use it. California also applies it to workers' comp. Other states use a two-prong test, a statutory checklist, or common-law control tests — see the state table.
Is the 2024 DOL independent contractor rule still in effect in 2026?
The 2024 rule remains on the books and governs private FLSA lawsuits, but the DOL's Wage and Hour Division stopped applying it in its own investigations on May 1, 2025 (Field Assistance Bulletin 2025-1) and enforces with Fact Sheet #13 (2008). A proposed rule published Feb. 27, 2026 would replace it with a modified 2021-style test centered on control and opportunity for profit or loss. As of Oct. 3, 2026 no final rule has been published.
Can a worker be a contractor for the IRS but an employee under state law?
Yes, and it happens often. The IRS uses the common-law control test, but a state that uses the ABC test for unemployment or wage law presumes employment unless the work is outside your usual course of business. A freelancer doing the same work your company sells can pass the IRS test and still fail prong B.
What is the penalty for misclassifying an employee?
Federally, when it wasn't intentional disregard, IRC § 3509 makes you pay the full employer share of FICA plus 1.5% of wages for income tax withholding and 20% of the employee's FICA share (3% and 40% if you didn't file 1099s). Workers can recover unpaid minimum wage and overtime plus an equal amount as liquidated damages under the FLSA. States add back unemployment tax, workers' comp premiums and their own penalties — e.g., California $5,000–$15,000 per violation for willful misclassification ($10,000–$25,000 for a pattern or practice) and Minnesota up to $10,000 per misclassified individual.
When do I have to file a 1099-NEC in 2026?
For payments made in 2026, file Form 1099-NEC when you pay a non-employee $2,000 or more for services (up from $600 under the One Big Beautiful Bill Act); the threshold may be adjusted for inflation starting in 2027. Payments by card or through payment apps are reported by the processor on Form 1099-K instead. Forms for 2026 are due Feb. 1, 2027 because Jan. 31 falls on a Sunday.
How do I fix a misclassification?
Start treating the worker as an employee going forward. For past federal employment taxes, the IRS Voluntary Classification Settlement Program settles prior years for 10% of the most recent year's liability at § 3509 reduced rates, with no interest or penalties — file Form 8952 at least 120 days before you reclassify. State unemployment and workers' comp exposure has to be handled with each state, ideally with an employment attorney.
Is a 1099 worker the same as an independent contractor?
Usually, but the form doesn't create the status. Issuing a 1099 to someone who is legally an employee doesn't make them a contractor — it's evidence of how you treated them, and it lowers your § 3509 rates if the IRS reclassifies them.
Official Sources
Figures checked against these sources on 2026-10-03
- irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employed/independent-contractor-self-employed-or-employee
- irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employed/voluntary-classification-settlement-program
- irs.gov/government-entities/worker-reclassification-section-530-relief
- law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/3509
- dol.gov/sites/dolgov/files/WHD/fab/fab2025-1.pdf
- federalregister.gov/documents/2026/02/27/2026-03962/employee-or-independent-contractor-status-under-the-fair-labor-standards-act-family-and-medical
- dol.gov/agencies/whd/flsa/misclassification/rulemaking
- oui.doleta.gov/unemploy/pdf/uilawcompar/2023/coverage.pdf
- irs.gov/instructions/i1099mec
- IRS Rev. Proc. 2025-32, § 4.24 (2026 § 179 limits) (irs.gov)
- 29 U.S.C. § 216(b) (Cornell LII) (law.cornell.edu)
- labor.mo.gov/media/pdf/irs-20-factor-test



